Now open to non-executive and advisory board roles. to board roles.Boards & advisory
  1. Home
  2. Insights
  3. Lead generation
Lead generation

Why I Shut Down Our Cold Email Programme

I closed our own cold email programme in August. It worked in the narrow sense that it created conversations. It failed on attention: it was never finished, never quiet, and the people keeping it alive were the people whose judgement the business runs on. One business, one decision, and not advice to stop doing outbound.

By Stephen EllulPublished 12 Oct 20267 min read
Why I Shut Down Our Cold Email Programme cover

In August I shut down our cold email programme. Not paused it, not rebuilt it with cleaner domains and a better list, shut it down and took the line for it off our own paperwork the same month. I run Growth Bully, a Malta performance marketing agency, so this is not a neutral observation about a channel. It is a decision I made about my own business, and I am writing it up because the honest version of these decisions almost never gets published by anyone who has made one.

Two things this is not. It is not advice to stop doing outbound, and it is not a cost comparison. My team has written the commercial version of that argument at thegrowthbully.com/bytes/cold-email-vs-paid-ads, and if you want the framework for deciding between the two channels, read that one instead. This is the story and the judgement behind it.

What did I think I was buying?

Predictable conversations with people who had never heard of us. That was the pitch I made to myself and it was not a fantasy, because the programme did produce conversations. What I had not priced is that a channel can deliver exactly what you asked of it and still be the wrong thing to own.

I bought it at a moment when the pipeline looked thin and the appeal was control. Advertising felt like renting attention from a platform that could change the rules. Outbound felt like owning the route to the buyer. That instinct was not stupid and it is the reason the channel sells so well to founders.

What did the programme actually cost?

Attention, not money. The outlay was modest and I could have carried it for years without noticing on a bank statement. What I could not carry is that the programme was never finished and never quiet, and the checking it demanded kept landing on the handful of people whose judgement the business genuinely runs on.

That is the cost nobody puts in the business case, because it does not have a number. Something was always slightly wrong. A sending domain needed attention, a list had gone stale, placement had moved for reasons nobody could explain, an inbox had replies sitting in it from the day before. None of it was difficult. All of it was unavoidable, and every piece of it arrived as an interruption to work that was worth more.

The tell was Monday mornings. The programme occupied the top of my head before anything a client was paying for did. A thing that small has no business being the first item of the week.

What were the replies really worth?

Less than the count suggested. A reply from outbound is not the same object as a reply from someone who came looking for you. One arrives mid-decision with the problem already named. The other arrives mildly curious, at my prompting, and still has to be persuaded that a problem exists before anything else can happen.

Once I started sorting them honestly, almost everything fell into four groups:

  • The polite no. Courteous, fast, and genuinely fine. These cost nothing and tell you nothing.
  • The information request. Send me something. Occasionally real, usually a softer way of saying no, and always expensive because it feels like progress.
  • The wrong person. Forwarded internally with good intentions and never seen again, because nobody inside the company owns the thing you asked about.
  • The real one. Someone who was already thinking about it before my message landed. These were worth having, and they were the smallest group by a distance.

The uncomfortable part is that last group. The conversations that went anywhere were nearly all with people who were already in motion. The message did not create the intent, it caught it, which raises an obvious question about the cheapest way to be present when intent appears.

What finally made the decision for me?

A comparison I had been avoiding. I stopped asking what the programme cost and asked where the same hours produced more pipeline. Framed in hours rather than euros the answer was not close, and the programme went from looking cheap to looking like the most expensive line we had.

I also stopped giving it credit for its best months. Any channel looks defensible if you judge it on the quarter it behaved. Judged on an average month, against what those same hours did elsewhere, it lost.

What replaced it?

Paid acquisition, a follow up process that treats an enquiry as urgent, and deliberate work on the specific conversations we actually wanted. Fewer names arrive now and more of them turn into something. That sounds like a slogan until you notice the second half is the only part that gets paid.

The follow up was the real unlock rather than the channel swap. Speed decides what an enquiry is worth, whatever produced it, and my team has the working at thegrowthbully.com/bytes/speed-to-lead. The named account work that used to justify the outbound programme now runs as a deliberate, researched process rather than a sending schedule, which is the part of outbound I never wanted to lose.

Was the programme a failure?

No, and I want to be precise about that, because failure is the convenient version of this story. It created conversations that would not otherwise have happened and it taught me more about how our buyers describe their own problems than any survey or workshop has. I would spend that money again for the education.

Three things I kept from it:

  1. The language. The phrases people used when they replied went straight into our adverts and our sales calls, and they outperformed anything written internally.
  2. The named list. Knowing exactly which companies could ever buy is useful regardless of how you reach them, and that work does not expire when the sending stops.
  3. The research habit. Reading a company properly before saying anything to it is a discipline worth keeping. The sending was the part I dropped.

Who should still be running cold email?

Anyone whose entire buyer list is short, named and unreachable another way. If you can write down the companies and the people on one page, no advertising platform can deliver to exactly them, and a researched personal approach is the only honest route to the conversation. That case is strong and nothing I decided touches it.

The conditions that make it worth the upkeep, and the arithmetic behind them, are set out properly in the channel comparison. If your market reads like that, keep going and ignore me.

What am I not claiming here?

That cold email is dead, that it cannot work, or that anyone running it is wasting their time. One business made one decision about where its scarcest resource goes. My market, my team size and the way we win work all fed into it, and change any of those and the answer changes with them.

What I would defend as general is narrower and duller. Price the attention a channel demands, not just the money. Judge it on an average month. And if the thing keeping a programme alive is the judgement of the two or three people your business depends on, that is not a cheap channel, whatever the invoice says.

If you would rather have the acquisition side run properly than argued about, that is the work my team does at Growth Bully.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why did you stop cold email?

Because of what it cost in attention rather than money. The programme was never finished and never quiet, and the upkeep kept interrupting the people whose judgement the business depends on. Compared in hours rather than euros against where those hours went instead, it lost clearly, so I closed it rather than rebuilt it.

Does cold email still work in 2026?

Yes, in the specific case it was always good at: a short, named buyer list that no advertising platform can target precisely. It works far less well as a volume channel, and in Europe the tactics that make volume cheap are the ones that create legal exposure. Take proper advice before running it.

What should I do instead of cold email?

Be present where intent already exists and respond to it faster than anyone else. In my case that meant paid acquisition plus a follow up process measured in minutes. The replies worth having were nearly all from people already thinking about the problem, so meeting that moment beats manufacturing it.

How do I know whether cold email is right for my business?

Count your buyers before comparing costs. If the complete list of companies that could ever buy fits on one page, outbound earns its upkeep and a named person should own it. If the list is large enough for a platform to find, buy the attention and spend the saved hours on following up properly.

Did stopping cold email hurt your pipeline?

Fewer names arrive and more of them become conversations, which is the trade I wanted. The honest caveat is that I changed the follow up process at the same time, so I cannot cleanly separate the two effects. One business, one decision, and not a controlled experiment anyone should generalise from.

Read next

Lead generation

B2B Appointment Setting in Malta: Buy a System, Not a Caller

Malta businesses buy appointment setting as a person: a caller, a VA, an offshore SDR. The ones that win buy a system they own. Here is the difference, and the maths behind it.

21 Aug 2026 · 8 min read
Lead generation

B2B Marketing in Malta: How to Grow in a Small, Tight-Knit Market

B2B marketing in Malta is a different game. Everyone knows everyone, cold outreach backfires, and word of mouth dominates. Here is what actually works for B2B growth in Malta.

21 Aug 2026 · 5 min read
Lead generation

How to Work Out What a Customer Is Worth When You Only Have Twenty of Them

To calculate customer lifetime value, multiply what a customer pays you per period by the number of periods they stay, then multiply by your gross margin. With a small client list you have no reliable churn rate, so use observed retention, the median rather than the average, and a deliberately short lifespan. Under about thirty customers it is a planning figure, not a measurement.

21 Nov 2026 · 7 min read

Book 30 minutes.

I'll look at where your leads come from today and tell you straight whether I can help.

Rather build it yourself? The 30-Day Pipeline™ walks you through it in your own accounts.

The Meta ads checklist

The checks I run on every new account before spending a euro.

Check your inbox. The checklist is on its way.