Now open to non-executive and advisory board roles. to board roles.Boards & advisory
  1. Home
  2. Insights
  3. Meta ads
Meta ads

Facebook Ads vs Instagram Ads: Where Your Budget Should Go

Facebook ads and Instagram ads are the same ads, bought in the same account, from the same budget. In most accounts the placement algorithm splits the spend better than a manual choice does. The question worth asking is not which platform, but whether your creative and your audience give the system anything useful to split.

By Stephen EllulPublished 4 Nov 20266 min read
Facebook Ads vs Instagram Ads: Where Your Budget Should Go cover

The Facebook ads versus Instagram ads question is asked as though two products are being compared. They are not. Both are bought in one Ads Manager, from one budget, inside one campaign, and Instagram is a placement in the same way that the Facebook feed, Stories, Reels and the audience network are placements. Nobody chooses between them at the account level unless they go out of their way to.

That matters, because the honest answer to “should I advertise on Facebook or Instagram” is usually “you already are”. If you have ever launched a campaign with Advantage+ placements on, your budget has been moving between the two surfaces continuously, reallocating towards wherever the result was cheaper that day. The decision you think you are making was made for you, repeatedly, on better information than you have.

So the useful version of this question is narrower. When is it worth taking that decision back?

Are Facebook ads and Instagram ads the same?

Mechanically, yes. Same account, same campaign structure, same targeting options, same optimisation events, same billing. The differences are in where the ad appears and what shape it has to be to work there. An ad running in the Facebook feed and the same ad running in Instagram Reels are the same purchase with two different sets of physics around it.

The practical difference people are actually noticing when they ask this question is audience. The two surfaces skew differently by age, and they skew differently by mindset. Instagram’s audience is younger on average and arrives in a visual, scrolling, entertainment posture. The Facebook feed carries more of the older end of the market, and more of the people who use the platform for groups, marketplace listings and local business pages rather than for discovery.

Neither of those is a reason to turn one off. Both are reasons to stop sending one asset to both.

Why does one placement always look cheaper?

Because cost per result at placement level is not a league table, it is a reflection of what the system found. A low cost per lead on one surface usually means the algorithm found the cheap, high-volume pocket of your audience there first, not that the surface is inherently better. Starve the other one and that pocket runs out faster than you expect.

This is where a lot of accounts go wrong. Someone reads the placement breakdown after a week, sees Instagram at half the cost per result, excludes Facebook, and watches the cost per result rise over the following fortnight. The cheap pocket was never the whole audience. It was the easiest part of it, and the campaign had been quietly using the expensive part to keep the learning stable.

Read placement data as diagnosis, not instruction. It tells you which creative is working where. It does not tell you to shut anything off.

Does creative format matter more than platform?

More than almost anything else in this comparison. The same message delivered as a square feed image and as a nine by sixteen Reel is two different ads with two different jobs, and the accounts that get a clean result on both surfaces are almost always the accounts that supplied both.

Three things follow from that:

  • Vertical video is the price of entry for Reels and Stories. A cropped landscape asset with a logo in the dead zone will underperform, and the placement report will blame the placement.
  • Feed rewards clarity, Reels rewards motion. A feed image can carry a proposition in text. A Reel has to earn the first second before it is allowed to say anything.
  • Instagram punishes anything that looks like an advert earlier. The threshold for “this is marketing” is lower there, which is why native, first-person, lightly produced assets travel better on that surface than studio work.

If you only have one asset, you do not have a platform question. You have an asset question, and it will show up as a placement problem for as long as you let it.

When should you force one placement?

Rarely, and only for a specific reason you can state in a sentence. The cases where it genuinely holds up are narrow:

  1. The creative only exists in one format, and will for the length of the test. Forcing the matching placement stops the system spending on a surface where your asset cannot compete.
  2. The audience is strongly skewed and you can prove it, from your own customer data rather than from a demographic article.
  3. You are testing a specific creative hypothesis and need the variable isolated for a fixed window, after which it goes back.
  4. Brand safety or compliance rules out a surface, which is a constraint rather than a strategy.

Everything else is usually a preference dressed as optimisation. If the reason you are excluding a placement is that you personally do not use that platform, that is not a reason, and it is a surprisingly common one.

What about the Instagram boost button?

Different question with a different answer, and worth separating cleanly: boosting from the app and running the same spend through Ads Manager are not comparable products, and the boost button loses on objective, targeting and measurement. I have written that comparison out properly in boosting versus Facebook ads, so it does not need relitigating here.

How should you actually set this up?

Start with placements on automatic, supply at least one vertical asset and one feed asset per audience, and let the system split. Then read the placement breakdown weekly as a creative report rather than a platform report: which asset is carrying which surface, and which surface has no viable asset at all.

That reading is where the real decisions live. Most accounts discover that they do not have an Instagram problem. They have a vertical creative problem, and once it is fixed the placement split stops being interesting. The detail of what the controls actually do, and which ones are worth touching, is in Meta ads placement controls, and the Reels-specific side is in Instagram Reels ads strategy.

The version I would run in almost any account: one campaign, automatic placements, feed and vertical assets for every audience, and a quarterly creative review instead of a monthly platform argument. If you want the commercial version of this run as a service, that sits with Growth Bully’s Meta ads work.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are Facebook ads and Instagram ads the same thing?

Mechanically yes. Both are bought in the same Ads Manager, from the same budget, with the same targeting and optimisation options. Instagram is a placement within a Meta campaign, not a separate product. What differs is where the ad appears, what format it needs, and which slice of the audience sees it.

Is it better to run ads on Facebook or Instagram?

Neither, in most accounts. Leaving placements automatic lets the system move budget towards whichever surface is cheaper that day, which it does better than a manual choice. Forcing one placement is only worth it when your creative exists in a single format, or when your own customer data shows a strong skew.

Why are Instagram ads cheaper than Facebook ads in my account?

Usually because the algorithm found the easy, high-volume pocket of your audience there first. That is a snapshot, not a ranking. Excluding the more expensive placement often pushes cost per result up within a fortnight, because the cheap pocket was only ever part of the audience you were buying.

Do I need different creative for Facebook and Instagram?

Yes, and this is the change that moves the result most. Supply at least one vertical nine by sixteen asset for Reels and Stories and one feed asset per audience. A cropped landscape video will underperform in vertical placements, and the placement report will read as a platform problem rather than an asset problem.

Should I use the Instagram boost button or Ads Manager?

Ads Manager, for anything you expect a measurable return from. Boosting restricts the objective, the targeting and the reporting, so it optimises for engagement when you usually want enquiries or sales. The same spend run through a proper campaign gives you placement control, conversion optimisation and usable data.

Read next

Meta ads

Facebook Ads for Restaurants: A Complete Guide

How to run Meta Ads for your restaurant: campaign objectives, local targeting, creative that converts, and how to measure results properly.

27 Oct 2026 · 5 min read
Meta ads

What Is a Good Cost Per Lead on Facebook Ads?

Industry CPL benchmarks for Facebook Ads in 2026, plus the exact formula to calculate your own target cost per lead from your business unit economics.

27 Oct 2026 · 6 min read
Meta ads

What Is a Good ROAS for Meta Ads? 2026 Benchmarks by Industry

A good ROAS for Meta Ads is typically 3x–5x for e-commerce, but varies significantly by industry and margin. Here's the full breakdown.

21 Aug 2026 · 5 min read

Book 30 minutes.

I'll look at where your leads come from today and tell you straight whether I can help.

Rather build it yourself? The 30-Day Pipeline™ walks you through it in your own accounts.

The Meta ads checklist

The checks I run on every new account before spending a euro.

Check your inbox. The checklist is on its way.